Semenyo vs. Mateta

Final Verdict: Mateta

Despite Semenyo's higher overall points this season, Mateta's more consistent recent starts and better form make him the safer and more practical choice for the upcoming gameweek.

Head-to-Head Analysis

Availability & Risk: Both players are fully available with no injury concerns, so this isn't a direct differentiator. However, Semenyo was benched in GW12, which raises questions about his guaranteed minutes.
Form: Mateta is currently in better form (2.8) compared to Semenyo (1.2). Semenyo has had a string of low scores and a recent benching, which is a major red flag for FPL managers.
Fixtures: Both have favourable fixtures in GW15 (Mateta vs BUR (A), Semenyo vs EVE (H)). Semenyo's subsequent fixtures (CHE H, MUN A) are arguably slightly better than Mateta's (FUL A, MCI H).
Value: Semenyo offers better points-per-million (10.39) at a lower price (7.7m) than Mateta (7.28 PPM at 8.1m). However, value only translates to points if the player is on the pitch and performing.
Underlying Stats: Semenyo boasts higher creativity and overall ICT Index, while Mateta has a significantly higher threat, indicating more goal-scoring opportunities. Mateta has more goals (7 vs 6), but Semenyo has more assists (4 vs 0).

The Deciding Factor

Semenyo's recent benching in GW12 and his abysmal form (averaging just 1.2 points per game over the last five gameweeks) are too big to ignore. Mateta, while not spectacular, is consistently starting and has shown more attacking returns recently, making him the more reliable option right now.

My Team Analysis

Gameweek Analysis

Player Analysis

Players Comparison

Team Analysis