Donnarumma (MCI, Goalkeeper, £5.7m)

Verdict: HOLD

Donnarumma is a nailed-on starter for Manchester City, and while his returns have been inconsistent, a favourable home fixture against Everton in Gameweek 8 makes him worth holding onto for now.

The Reasoning

Fitness & Availability: Donnarumma is fully available and a nailed-on starter for Manchester City, with no injury concerns reported. This is a significant plus for a premium asset.
Recent Performance: His recent form has been a mixed bag, with two clean sheets in the last four gameweeks but also a 1-pointer and a 2-pointer. While Man City's defence hasn't been as impenetrable as expected, he did manage a 6-point haul last gameweek.
Upcoming Fixtures: Gameweek 8 presents a prime opportunity for a clean sheet at home against Everton (difficulty 2.0). This is followed by a tougher away trip to Aston Villa (difficulty 4.0) and then a home tie against Bournemouth (difficulty 3.0). The immediate fixture is very appealing.
Underlying Stats: As a goalkeeper, his ICT Index of 4.9 is expectedly low. His influence is decent, reflecting his role in a dominant team, but his overall points-per-million of 2.63 is not justifying his premium price tag so far.

Risks

The primary risk for Donnarumma is his premium £5.7m price tag not being consistently justified by returns. While Man City's defence is strong on paper, they've only managed two clean sheets in seven games, which is below expectations for a top-tier team. The fixture against Aston Villa in GW9 is also a tough one.

Alternative Options

If you're looking to free up funds, cheaper options like Alphonse Areola (£4.2m) or Neto (£4.5m) could offer similar or better value, allowing investment elsewhere. For a similar premium price, you might consider Alisson (£5.5m) or Ederson (£5.5m) if you prefer a different top-six goalkeeper with potentially more consistent clean sheet potential.

The Strategic Play

For managers who already own Donnarumma, holding him for the enticing Everton home fixture in Gameweek 8 is the sensible move. If he blanks or City's defensive form doesn't improve significantly after that, then reassessing his value and potentially downgrading to a cheaper, more reliable option to free up funds would be a wise strategic play. For those without him, it's probably an AVOID for now, as his price demands more consistent returns.

My Team Analysis

Gameweek Analysis

Player Analysis

Players Comparison

Team Analysis